she waited in the tower and twirled her hair ([info]ifyouweremine) wrote,
  • Mood: rushed

I love Percy Weasley because...

For some reason, I am on a Percy kick lately. ^__~
The following is blamed entirely on devoted to [info]mauraders, a fellow Percy fan who asked why we, personally, loved Percy.
#huggles [info]mauraders# ^__^
Btw, I don’t know how coherent this came out, so, sorry for anything that makes absolutely no sense! =o) I’d usually do a better job of deleting/rephrasing anything that looked too bizarre, but I’ve got to run to class! #rushes#


I love Percy because he’s human, and he’s fallible, and he tries too hard.

I love him because he always does what he thinks is the right thing; because he’s smart and he’s brave, and obsessive and dysfunctional and naïve, and people don’t give him the respect and affection I whole-heartedly believe he deserves.

I love Percy because he’s not a cookie-cutter character of “Good” in a poster-family of hot-headed virtue.

I love Percy because he’s complex, and uptight, and I think he deserves to be able to relax and be truly happy for once in his life.

I love him because he’s a misfit and he’s awkward and he gets dumped on and dismissed by everyone he knows, yet still runs, terrified, into the lake to make sure his brother is okay—even when he knows he must be, the rules say so, but—he just has to make sure, because he loves his family so much, even when I sometimes honestly think they might not deserve it.

I love him for his innocence, and his loss of innocence, and his convictions; I love him for, for the first time in his life, taking a chance by sticking to what he believed in—even if it did backfire—because that, whether you want to admit it or not, took guts. It was brave and stupid and painful and justifiable, and he did it—he went through with it, that brilliant, beautiful kid, and people need to stop having hissy-fits about it and start judging their own favorites by those same, harsh standards if they want to go around pointing fingers and crying foul.

I love Percy because he’s focused and neurotic and hard-working and prim; I love that he’s priggish and prudish and misjudged, and so entirely human in his self-imposed and outwardly-inflicted ordeals that it just might tear you apart.

I love him because he’s repressed and alone, and really, really just needs a big hug and a listening ear and someone’s solid shoulder to cry on, if he could ever actually allow himself to break down and let that part of him out—though he never would; it’s too painful, too frightening, and he’s sure it’ll go away with enough reports on cauldron-bottoms, so long as he doesn’t think about it, and I love him for that, too.

I love him because he’s so fucked-up, and that’s so real—I can relate to that; I can let him inside my heart and take the chance that that might hurt me, because, what else can I do? I can’t harden myself to someone so impossibly familiar by the very virtue of his perfect imperfections. I haven’t the heart to refuse this persecuted man-child; I can’t deprive him of my sympathy/affection/understanding. That seems far too cruel for my tastes.

I love him because there’s a definite chance he won’t get a happy ending.

I love him because loads of people don’t want him to have a happy ending.

I love him because he’s been taught to always follow the rules, and he did, and it’s not fair that devoting yourself to doing everything you were brought up to do could still make you so miserable.

I love him because he gets locked up in pyramids during family vacations and bratty second-years challenge his authority, and does anyone see something fundamentally wrong with that?

I love him because he needs love; he needs someone with no expectations or insincerity to appreciate and care about him for no other reason except that he is himself, and that’s more than enough, and I love that he needs that, and that he tries to earn it by working himself to the bone.

I love him ’cause I bet he’d be stiff and cool and confused and uncomfortable yet still polite if you ever tried to hug him, and if you kept it up I think he might just melt, because he needs that, and I think a lot of people forget that. I think he forgets that.

I love him because I want to see the stern, terse/disapproving line of his mouth curl into a smile.

I love him because he really has no clue at all about what he’s doing; because I bet he’s all alone in an empty flat, and probably has a wilting plant named Murphy set out on the windowsill to look nice for the company that never comes, and I think he talks to it at ten o’clock at night (when he finally tears himself from work and Apparates home) as he searches for something to eat in his empty kitchen, just to hear the sound of someone’s—anyone’s—voice. And why not? It’s better than that thick, disturbing silence.

I love him because I want him to have something—someone?—that he’ll leave work early for. A hobby or a girlfriend (boyfriend?), or maybe a cat. Something like that.

I love him because I don’t want to see his character bastardized or chastised or desensitized and empty or dead. Not that—never that.

I love him because he’s too easy to sacrifice—he’s too susceptible to being “made an example of,” and it’s terribly important to love him now before the next book or the book after that comes along and ruins everything. Just in case.

In short, I love Percy because he’s human; his strength/fragility is precious, and it’s okay that he’s not “perfect,” even though he tries so hard. I love him for his faults and for his virtues—for his mistakes and his accomplishments and his devotion. And I love him, also, for the simple fact that so very, very few people do. And he deserves better than that.

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Your reply will be screened

  • 27 comments

[info]mauraders

September 30 2004, 12:43:03 UTC 7 years ago

You just made me cry. In a good way, of course.

I love Percy for all of the above reasons.

I want to hug him, too. He needs lots of hugs and kisses. Platonic, romantic, familial -- all kinds.

*wipes away tears and hugs Percy again*

And just for good measure -- *huggles YOU*

[info]atalantapendrag

September 30 2004, 13:39:00 UTC 7 years ago

Yes, yes, yes, every word of that could have been taken from my own heart.

[info]etherealshores

September 30 2004, 15:29:45 UTC 7 years ago

DUDE.That was so beautiful.

He just wants the best for himself and his family..yet people hate him for that too!!

*Loves Percy*

[info]hermione_like

September 30 2004, 15:44:24 UTC 7 years ago

Rock on. I agree with everything you said. :D

[info]___destijl

September 30 2004, 15:47:08 UTC 7 years ago

Beautiful. This is exactly why I love him.

[info]saturniia

September 30 2004, 16:03:46 UTC 7 years ago

Wow... you've said maybe everything I think, and I was just wondering if I could credit you and link to your list in an entry in my own journal, because that list is poetry.

And isn't it such a shame that in J.K. Rowling's world, the only "complete" characters, the ones who are shown as imperfect and vulnerable and maybe even "real", are outcast if their name isn't Harry Potter? I mean, sure Ron is the youngest boy of seven children, and his younger sister's a handful and between his successful eldest brothers, rebelling Percy, and the clever twins he's sometimes overlooked, and he sometimes gets angry about being in Harry's shadow, he's loved... unconditionally. And Hermione may suffer from being a bit too book smart and the stigma of not being born into a Wizarding family, but she's still a part of the action, still gets the guy everyone wants as her date to the Yule Ball in fourth year. Harry... well, Harry's allowed to be imperfect because he's the hero. If he was good all the time, and solid, and dependable, the books wouldn't be interesting. But he's the only one allowed to mess up in Rowling's world, because if you make the "wrong" choice, like Percy, or treat the hero like a student instead of like a celebrity, like Snape, you're suddenly "evil", because Harry sees you as such.

[info]ifyouweremine

September 30 2004, 16:22:15 UTC 7 years ago

I’m glad you liked it! ^__^
And of course you can link it in your journal—I’m surprised and flattered that you like it enough to want to do that! #huggles# =o)
Also, yes, I completely agree with you about that whole OMG-Harry-doesn’t-like-so-and-so-they-must-be-EVIL!!1!!11! phenomenon that’s all too common among the majority of the fandom. Having a different opinion doesn’t automatically mean you’re a Death Eater. #rolls eyes#
Thanks for the comment—bye! #hearts#

<33333333333333333,
Miranda

[info]elisa0984

September 30 2004, 17:06:56 UTC 7 years ago

That was absolutely fucking wonderful. I've been taking some time lately considering the fact that everything in the books is from Harry's view and how distorted that really is. It makes me so much more for other characters, especially Percy. I'm adding this to my memories.

[info]culuyetille

September 30 2004, 19:48:49 UTC 7 years ago

I loved this Percy rant; it is so heartfelt and wonderful. *huggles*
Here's some happiness and secret rule disregarding for Percy and some giddiness for you, love. In case you aren't registered at RestrictedSection I highly advise you to do that NOW. Have fun!

(both Percy/Oliver, because as you said, Percy deserves some carefreeness and someone honest and simple and cheerful and Oli fulfills, when he's not being ObsessiveCoach ;) )

http://www.restrictedsection.org/file.php?file=1147

http://www.restrictedsection.org/file.php?file=1919

[info]dr_jasley

September 30 2004, 21:30:58 UTC 7 years ago

wow...stummbled here and read your post...awesome..I agree with everything you typed....I'm not a huge potter fan(only read one complete book) but I love percy...cause he is flawed..I hate it when people bash him..I mean what would you do if you were put into his shoes? I know I'd walk out tooo...and it's like as a prefect(then later head boy) Percy is dispised(last time I checked nice fluffy people holding those kind of positions get walked all over and every thing) though percy gets walked over anyways(authority figures are not suppossed to be all lollie pops and ice cream...an authority figure need to be firm) umm just my opinion.. sorry.. and guhhh I hate the whole he left his family so now he's a traitor..WTF...walking away from your family(last time I checked) it didn't mean "DeathEater" or that he didn't love them(his family)

umm yeah I'm going to go now...sorry for the long comment(this is a subject I tend to get very verbal about)

[info]melloniel

September 30 2004, 22:15:41 UTC 7 years ago

I agree with every. Last. Word. <3!

[info]muffytaj

October 1 2004, 07:03:37 UTC 7 years ago

Exactly. I've always felt that he was treated far too harshly. I mean, how is he that different from how Hermione was at the start? But I'm willing to bet he never had a troll come around to help him make friends.

I wish someone would just give Percy a hug. *weepy now*

[info]ifyouweremine

October 1 2004, 08:59:12 UTC 7 years ago

Hey, Tohru and Kisa!
So, you like Fruits Basket and Percy? #squee# That’s it, you are TEH COOL in my book. ^__^
Of course, being the nosey curious person I am, I checked out your journal/user info and was—understandably—utterly charmed, so, yes. Am friending you now, if that’s okay. ^__~ <33333333333333

—Miranda

[info]muffytaj

7 years ago

[info]priscellie

October 1 2004, 15:03:33 UTC 7 years ago

I'm close to tears. If you don't mind, I'd like to link to this in my blog. I think more people need to see this.

[info]ifyouweremine

October 1 2004, 15:41:54 UTC 7 years ago

Wow—thank you, I’m glad you liked it! And feel free to link it, as well—I’m immensely flattered that you enjoyed it enough to want to do that! #hearts#

<33333333333333333333,
Miranda

[info]unravels

October 1 2004, 15:32:54 UTC 7 years ago

As a non-Percy fan (not that I hate him, I just never really understood the devout love I'd seen in various places), this is really, er, illuminating. I have a bizarre urge to read Percy genfic now, and if that isn't a sign of a successful rant, I don't know what is. ;)

But I still wonder - do you really hate evil!Percy fics? Because while I never really considered it a canon possibility in OotP, I had always thought that it was one of the more fascinating character paths for him. I mean, I love Harry for some of the same reasons - fucked up, needs love, people think the wrong things about him, etc. - but I also really like reading evil!Harry. To me, with Percy (and sometimes Harry), I think he'd make a fantastic villain because of all the angst, the abuse from others, the obsession with doing the right thing. He/they would be so good at it! But maybe you've seen so much of that that it's like overkill? I haven't looked, so I really don't know what's out there.

Side note: I have Winamp and STILL can not hear your phone posts. Woe! Maybe I need the full version or something. Will tinker this weekend.

[info]swussian

October 2 2004, 01:29:42 UTC 7 years ago

Percy is God and Boba Fett.

Percy has been my favourite for years. It's always nice to see that more people like him, for very good reasons too.
I have recently met a guy who reminds me on Percy and whom I developed a crush on (of course). Watching a person act competently, still always looking for approval without even knowing it IRL has made me love my Percy even more.

[info]veracity

October 9 2004, 20:47:49 UTC 7 years ago

Here via [info]weasleyworship
Those are same reasons I love him. For all his behaviour, he's true to his character. Far more than anyone other, I believe. He made a mistake in judgment, but who doesn't? We all have to spread our wings and fly. Sometimes we don't get it right the first time, but it's still necessary to try. I loved that you called him Misjudged, because I've been saying that for over a year. He cares about his family, tries to get them to follow the rules so they stay out of trouble.

Misguided in his flight plan, but in a family of rebels, he's truly the rebel. The rest follow the side the parents on are, he took a chance with the Ministry (the place he's always been told is the one place you should turn too in need) and it turned out badly, but he stood his ground. Why is that frowned upon? He took a chance; isn't that what Weasleys do?

He cared about Ginny when she was taken to the Chamber, but people overlook that. Why? It shows a deep loyalty to the family, in my opinion at least. He was looking out for Ron in that letter, whether people realize it or not. It was the only way Percy knew how to save his baby brother.

How can someone not love a character that sticks to his principles?

Anonymous

October 24 2004, 14:56:27 UTC 7 years ago

yay for PErcy!

I just cried... this is so true! I love Percy for the exact same reasons, and it almost upsets me that he's a fictional character that I can't hug! You did a lovely job of this, and I really think that J.K. should give PErcy a happy ending, or a resolution, or a boyfriend... or a cat. All would be nice. Thank you for making me cry tears of joy, and for making me think.
My livejournal is on GreatestJournal.com, and my username's Percybabe16. we should talk!

[info]mlle_skeetre

October 28 2004, 05:17:52 UTC 7 years ago

Unfashionably late, as always, but:

Hear, hear.

Also, may I friend you?

[info]ifyouweremine

October 28 2004, 06:58:59 UTC 7 years ago

Re: Unfashionably late, as always, but:

Thank you, I’m glad you enjoyed it!
Also: of course you may friend me—I love making new friends! #friends you at once# ^_____^

<33333333333333333333333333,
Miranda

[info]merelyn

December 2 2004, 06:55:49 UTC 7 years ago

Here from [info]percy_fans, and I'm totally late to the party, but this is wonderful.

[info]snakelights

June 10 2005, 03:42:56 UTC 6 years ago

So-So- god this is why I liked percy out of all the weasely's (except for Ron, and more than ron too sometimes). Out of all charchtars he is the most realistically fallible. We never get to see him in the good light.

[info]_tanglewood_

September 22 2006, 18:02:29 UTC 5 years ago

I loved this. It rang so true. And I also think that sometimes the Weasley's don't deserve Percy. And that Percy desperatley needs a hug.And if i can't give it to him then i will imagine Oliver doing it in my stead.

*Memories*

Thanks for posting this.

[info]bloodanna

July 2 2007, 23:49:45 UTC 4 years ago

Yes, yes! EXACTLY!
This is exactly why I love him!
His utterly human responses, and his hurt, his loneliness, his perfectly human imperfections and flaws. Few people ever think to look past the Harry bias of the books, at the hearts of the "bad" characters and for that reason I love this. This post is like a breath of fresh air.


*memories it*
Create an Account
Forgot your login or password?
Facebook Twitter More login options
English • Español • Deutsch • Русский…